Davis Webb and the Denver Broncos: A Bold Strategy or a Costly Mistake?

The NFL is known for its high-stakes gambles, but few decisions have sparked as much debate recently as Denver Broncos head coach Sean Payton handing the play-calling reins to offensive coordinator Davis Webb. While Payton sees a “gift” in the young coach, critics—most notably former NFL head coach and current analyst Rex Ryan—are calling it a critical error.

The Controversy: Rex Ryan Weighs In

During an appearance on ESPN’s “NFL Sunday Countdown,” Rex Ryan didn’t hold back his opinion on the Broncos’ new offensive hierarchy. Ryan argued that Sean Payton’s historical success is inextricably linked to his brilliance as a play-caller.

“I thought it was a mistake from jump,” Ryan stated. “Sean Payton is one of the best play-callers in the history of our game. And you know who else knows it? His team knows it.”

Ryan emphasized that while great assistant coaches are vital, the synergy of having a head coach who also dictates the offensive flow is what sets elite teams apart. He compared this to his own tenure, noting that while he had exceptional coordinators like Mike Pettine and Dennis Thurman, the ultimate strategic vision remained his own.

The Hard Truth: Analyzing the Numbers

The debate isn’t just about opinions; it’s about performance. In Davis Webb’s first regular-season game as the primary play-caller, the Broncos suffered a bruising 31-10 loss against the Kansas City Chiefs. The statistics paint a worrying picture for Denver fans:

n
• Total Yards: A meager 176 yards.
• Running Game: The ball was handed off only 12 times, indicating a severe lack of balance.
• Late Game Struggle: The offense managed only 109 yards over their final 37 plays.

After the game, even Payton acknowledged the imbalance, noting there were “lotta throws, not enough runs.” For a team looking to compete in a tough division, these efficiency issues are a major red flag.

Who is Davis Webb?

At just 31 years old, Davis Webb is one of the youngest coordinators in the league. A former backup quarterback for the Buffalo Bills, Webb transitioned into coaching and worked with Denver’s quarterbacks throughout 2023 and 2024. His ascent to offensive coordinator came after the team parted ways with Joe Lombardi.

Payton has remained steadfast in his support, stating back in February that he would only make this move if it benefited the team, citing Webb’s innate talent for the game.

Looking Ahead: The Jacksonville Test

The Broncos now face a daunting task as they prepare to host the Jacksonville Jaguars. With the Jaguars riding a nine-game winning streak and a history of beating Denver in recent matchups, the pressure is on Webb to prove he can adapt.

Will Sean Payton maintain his trust in Webb, or will the mounting criticism and poor offensive output force him to reclaim the play-calling duties? Only time—and the scoreboard—will tell.

Stay tuned to the official NFL news for more updates on the Denver Broncos’ season.