Auston Matthews: A Maple Leafs Crossroads?
Before Connor McDavid re-signed with the Edmonton Oilers, he made his expectations crystal clear: the team needed to be a legitimate contender. McDavid navigated a tense summer, causing Oilers fans considerable anxiety, ultimately signing a short-term, two-year extension. Now, according to analyst Nick Kypreos, Auston Matthews might be prepared to employ a similar tactic.
While some Toronto Maple Leafs fans may be indifferent to Matthews potentially leaving, others will be deeply affected. However, the resurgence of the ‘old’ Matthews – the dominant force Leafs Nation remembers – is a positive sign. Ironically, his improved performance could simultaneously create unease among those same fans, as it amplifies his leverage.
A Slow Start and a Dramatic Turnaround
Early in the 2023-24 season, Matthews appeared a shadow of his former self. He lacked his usual speed, energy, and engagement. Whether due to injury, system adjustments, new linemates, or underlying frustration, the Maple Leafs struggled, finding themselves outside the playoff picture.
Now, with Matthews back to scoring at will and consistently driving the team forward, the Leafs are a far more dangerous opponent. This on-ice leadership provides him with significant negotiating power, especially considering the numerous changes within the organization.
As Kypreos notes, Matthews has witnessed shifts in ownership, the front office, coaching staff, and, crucially, the lineup. He’s observed the depletion of the team’s prospect pool and draft capital, and seen star players like Matthew Tkachuk (Calgary Flames, 2022) and Quinn Hughes (Vancouver Canucks, 2024) seek opportunities elsewhere. The question is: could Matthews consider a similar move?
A Superstar’s Patience Wears Thin
Matthews’ recent, blunt response to questions about Mitch Marner may be the first indication that he’s no longer willing to wait. Kypreos suggests this is a superstar who’s done being patient. For a franchise burdened by high expectations and a history of falling short, Matthews is running out of time to achieve success.
Kypreos emphasizes that, like McDavid, Matthews needs concrete evidence that Toronto is committed to building a Stanley Cup contender. He needs assurance that the goaltending is reliable, the defense is solid, the supporting cast provides grit and resilience, and the team can perform even when he’s on the bench.
Leverage and a Two-Year Window
With two years remaining on his contract after this season, Matthews strategically positioned himself to evaluate the Leafs while still in his prime, mirroring McDavid’s approach with the Oilers. Kypreos believes the message is clear: build a legitimate Stanley Cup contender, or risk losing Matthews.
Matthews’ questioning of the team’s direction is understandable. Toronto has depleted its draft capital, repeatedly reshuffled the roster, and undergone frequent changes in coaching philosophies. Goaltending remains a constant concern, and star players are seeking opportunities elsewhere. A playoff miss would drastically alter the conversation, with contract negotiations (or the lack thereof) speaking volumes.
The Stakes are High
The Maple Leafs need a deep playoff run. Matthews needs confidence in the organization’s future and its ability to remain competitive. He wants to be part of a team that can win consistently, not one solely reliant on his individual brilliance.
If he doesn’t see a clear path to contention, Toronto could find itself in the same precarious position Edmonton once faced: desperately trying to convince its best player that patience is still worthwhile.
Source: The Hockey Writers
