The Secret Proposal and the Bachelorette Heartbreak
Reality TV is known for its twists and turns, but few stories are as tumultuous as that of Taylor Frankie Paul. The founder of the infamous “MomTok” group has finally opened up about the events surrounding her tenure as the lead on The Bachelorette—a season that viewers will likely never see on television.
In a revealing clip from the upcoming fifth season of Hulu’s The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, Paul shared a shocking detail: she actually got engaged during filming. While the world saw a cancelled production, Paul experienced a whirlwind romance that led to a surprise proposal.
A Strange Coincidence: Doug Mason vs. Dakota Mortensen
During a conversation with fellow cast members Jessi Draper, Mikayla Matthews, and Mayci Neeley, a strange pattern emerged. Paul’s final choice on the season, Doug Mason, bears an uncanny resemblance to her ex-boyfriend and the father of one of her children, Dakota Mortensen.
- n
- Same Initials: Both men share the same first and last initials.
- Same Origin: Both hail from the state of Idaho.
While Paul admitted she didn’t notice these similarities until later, the irony wasn’t lost on her co-stars, adding another layer of complexity to her romantic narrative.
Why ABC Pulled the Plug
Despite the engagement and the excitement of a new beginning, the season never made it to air. Just three days before the scheduled premiere on March 22, ABC took the drastic step of canceling the season. This decision followed the release of explosive video footage by TMZ, which detailed the events leading up to Paul’s 2023 arrest following a domestic dispute with Dakota Mortensen.
Paul eventually pleaded guilty to aggravated assault as part of a plea agreement. The fallout was immediate, not only costing her a spot on a major franchise but also pausing production on The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives.
Return to Utah and the Cycle of Drama
The most captivating part of the reveal comes after the cameras stopped rolling. Paul confesses that upon returning home to Utah, she re-established contact with Dakota Mortensen. In a move that has sparked intense speculation among fans, Paul hinted that the two reunited, suggesting that the engagement to Doug Mason vanished as quickly as it had appeared.
What to Expect Next
The rollercoaster of legal battles, public scandals, and romantic upheavals will be fully chronicled in the new season of her reality show. After production delays and further investigations into domestic violence allegations—which the Salt Lake County District Attorney’s Office ultimately decided not to pursue with new charges—the show is finally returning.
