A Shocking Turn in ‘Tell Me Lies’ Season 3: Lucy’s Complex Journey
The first three episodes of ‘Tell Me Lies’ Season 3 have left viewers reeling, and one scene, in particular, has sparked intense discussion. The encounter between Lucy and Alex (played by Costa D’Angelo), an acquaintance of Bree’s, is a pivotal moment, marked by a disturbing request from Lucy: to be called “pathetic.” This scene, powerfully intercut with Lucy’s confession about fabricating a sexual assault claim, is undeniably intense and raises profound questions about her character.
Behind the Scenes: Showrunner’s Perspective
Showrunner Meaghan Oppenheimer discussed the scene with Variety, revealing her initial reaction: “I was like, we’re really doing it. We’ll see what people say.” She praised both actors’ performances, stating, “I thought they both did so well in that scene. I thought it was beautiful, and I haven’t seen anything like it before.” Oppenheimer highlighted Costa D’Angelo’s ability to bring vulnerability to a character initially written as harder.
In an interview with The Hollywood Reporter, Oppenheimer delved into Lucy’s motivations, explaining, “She’s in such a shame spiral that she believes this is what she deserves. Also, there’s a part of her that has learned with her relationship with Stephen to conflate chemistry with toxicity. I think she’s gotten so used to that being part of what is sexual for her that she can’t give it up, and so she’s a little bit addicted to it.”
Lucy’s Search for Shame and Punishment
Grace Van Patten, who portrays Lucy, offered further insight to Decider, stating, “I think Lucy is just seeking shame and punishment, because she thinks that’s what she deserves. She’s gotten into a headspace with Stephen where she’s so used to being turned on by toxicity that it’s hard for her to get away from that. And Alex is sort of a safe space for her to explore those darker impulses.” This suggests a deeply ingrained pattern of self-destructive behavior fueled by past trauma and unhealthy relationship dynamics.
What’s Next?
Episode 4 of ‘Tell Me Lies’ Season 3 is set to drop on January 20th, promising further unraveling of Lucy’s complex psyche and the consequences of her actions. The show continues to push boundaries, exploring the darker aspects of love, trauma, and self-destruction.
Related Reads
- All About the ‘Tell Me Lies’ Cast’s Love Lives
- I Thought I Was Asexual—Turns Out, I Was Just Having Bad Sex
- Amanda Seyfried Says Channing Tatum Peed on Her Leg
A Part of Hearst Digital Media. We may earn commission from links on this page, but we only recommend products we back. ©2026 Hearst Magazine Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
