Taylor Frankie Paul and Dakota Mortensen Face New Domestic Violence Investigation
Recent reports indicate a deepening legal situation for stars of the Hulu reality series, “Secret Lives of Mormon Wives,” Taylor Frankie Paul and Dakota Mortensen. Authorities are currently investigating new allegations of domestic violence, adding another layer to a complex and troubling situation.
Details of the Investigation
According to a police spokesman, Dakota Mortensen contacted the West Jordan, Utah, Police Department last month alleging domestic violence against Taylor Frankie Paul stemming from an incident in 2024. The department is currently reviewing multiple videos related to the alleged event to establish a clear timeline and understanding of the circumstances. Currently, the investigation relies solely on Mortensen’s account, and police have yet to interview Paul directly, though they have been in contact with her legal counsel.
This isn’t the first instance of legal scrutiny for the pair. Draper police are also conducting a separate, open investigation into allegations of domestic violence involving both Paul and Mortensen, with claims made by both parties. Salt Lake County District Attorney Sam Gill has confirmed his office is reviewing investigative materials for potential charges, noting a prior plea in abeyance to a domestic violence offense could lead to enhanced charges if filed.
Past Legal Issues and Recent Developments
Court records reveal that Taylor Frankie Paul pleaded guilty in abeyance to an aggravated assault charge in August 2023, stemming from a February 2023 domestic violence incident. Several other charges from that case were dismissed. Footage from the 2023 arrest was featured on “Secret Lives of Mormon Wives,” the show that propelled Paul to prominence.
The situation escalated after TMZ published a video appearing to show Paul attacking Mortensen, reportedly depicting the incident that led to her 2023 arrest. This prompted ABC to pull Paul’s season of “The Bachelorette,” which was slated to premiere Sunday.
Statements and Production Halt
Paul’s spokesperson stated she is “very grateful for ABC’s support” and is prioritizing her family’s safety. The spokesperson also alleged years of “extensive mental and physical abuse” and “threats of retaliation,” claiming Paul is now taking steps to protect herself and her children. Paul herself stated she “will have my truth.”
Filming for Season Five of “Mormon Wives” has been paused as the legal proceedings unfold. Sources indicate the cast unanimously agreed to halt production until the situation is resolved. Hulu executives reportedly witnessed cast members discussing the allegations during filming, further contributing to the decision.
Cast Concerns and Support
Audio from a March 7th call reveals cast members raised concerns about Paul’s behavior with ABC executives prior to the emergence of the new allegations. Fellow cast member Jessi Draper, in an interview with Alex Cooper on “Call Her Daddy,” expressed empathy for Paul while acknowledging the disturbing nature of the newly released video, stating, “It’s just…there’s so much pain underneath the surface for Taylor.” Draper emphasized the need for this to be a “wake-up call” for both Paul and Mortensen.
Season Four of “Mormon Wives” premiered on March 12th, but the future of the show remains uncertain as the investigation continues.
(CORRECTION: A previous version of this article incorrectly stated the date of Paul’s guilty plea. It was August 2023, not August 2025.)
