Beyond the Notes: The Legacy of Music Critic Sylvain Cormier
For over thirty years, Sylvain Cormier has been more than just a journalist; he has been the rhythmic heartbeat of music criticism in Quebec. With a career spanning 35 years at the prestigious daily Le Devoir, Cormier has authored nearly 5,000 articles, blending deep-dive interviews with sharp album and concert reviews.
His influence on the cultural landscape is undeniable. Whether he was praising a hidden gem or delivering a scathing critique, Cormier’s writing has always been characterized by a unique blend of passion, precision, and an unwavering commitment to the art of songwriting.
“Des oreilles au bout des doigts”: A Musical Time Capsule
While Cormier often viewed himself as a journalist of the “immediate,” his friend and fellow journalist Louise Dugas saw a larger purpose in his archives. This collaboration resulted in the publication of “Des oreilles au bout des doigts”, a compelling collection of his best texts documenting three decades of Quebec’s musical evolution.
The book is far more than a simple “Best Of.” It is a historical journey featuring iconic artists such as:
- n
- Michel Rivard and Jean-Pierre Ferland: The pillars of the chanson tradition.
- Jean Leloup and Charlotte Cardin: The innovators of sound.
- Les Cowboys Fringants: The voice of a generation.
A “Fan with a Job”: Redefining Music Journalism
Sylvain Cormier famously resists the label of a strict journalist, preferring to describe himself as a “fan with a job.” This philosophy shifted the dynamic of his interviews from the pursuit of the “scoop” to a space of complicity and genuine exchange.
One of Cormier’s most significant contributions was his challenge to the elitism often associated with high-brow media. He championed “popular” artists—those often dismissed as quétaines (cheesy)—such as Michel Louvain, Patrick Norman, and René Simard. By giving these artists intellectual legitimacy, he bridged the gap between popular appeal and critical acclaim.
The Edge of the Pen: Controversies and Truths
Honesty is the currency of a great critic, and Cormier never hesitated to spend it. While he sought connection, he was not complacent. His book dedicates an entire chapter to the artists he “took down,” including figures like Garou and Claude Dubois.
However, his most famous clash was with the global icon Céline Dion, whom he once referred to as the “Tupperware Princess.” This critical stance led to a legendary and irreconcilable rift with René Angélil, proving that Cormier was willing to stand alone against the tide of global stardom to maintain his artistic integrity.
Full Circle: From the Page to the Stage
Writing was always a natural instinct for Cormier—starting as early as age nine with summaries of Hawaii Five-O. Yet, the siren song of performance never truly left him. After a brief stint with the group White Style & Friends in the late 70s, Cormier is making a triumphant return to his rock roots in 2024.
He has recently formed the group Les Grillons, collaborating with former members of legendary bands like Octobre, Beau Dommage, and Les Jaguars. This transition from the scribe to the performer completes a beautiful circle, proving that while he spent decades with “ears at the end of his fingers,” he still possesses the soul of a musician.
