Is the IPL Hurting Team India? Sanjay Manjrekar Warns Against the ‘IPL Make-up’

The Indian Premier League (IPL) is undoubtedly one of the most successful sporting leagues globally, bringing unprecedented glamour and financial growth to cricket. However, a growing debate is emerging: Is the glitz of the IPL compromising the performance of the Indian national team in international waters?

Former India batter Sanjay Manjrekar recently took to social media to voice a critical assessment of the current state of Indian T20I cricket. Following a string of disappointing overseas results—including a forgettable tour where India struggled against Ireland and suffered a heavy blow from England—Manjrekar argues that the problem isn’t just with the players, but with the system itself.

The Concept of ‘IPL Make-up’

Manjrekar introduced a provocative term: “IPL make-up.” He suggests that the conditions within the IPL create a deceptive image of a player’s true skill level. Because the league often features batting-friendly pitches, small boundaries, and minimal assistance for bowlers, players may appear more dominant than they actually are.

According to Manjrekar, this “make-up” hides technical flaws that are immediately exposed when players face challenging overseas conditions. He urges selectors to look beyond the flashing lights of the IPL and prioritize players who possess the technical grit required for international cricket outside of India.

Why the IPL Environment is Controversial

Critics of the current IPL format highlight several key issues that could be hindering national team growth:

n
• Batting-Friendly Surfaces: Flat pitches encourage raw power-hitting over traditional stroke-making and strategic innings building.
• Lack of Bowler Support: With limited assistance for bowlers, the art of swing and seam is often sidelined in favor of variations and spin.
• The ‘Home Fun Run’: Manjrekar warns that the era of easy home wins is over, and the team must now adapt to the rigors of global tours.

The Impact Player Rule: A Double-Edged Sword?

It’s not just the pitches causing concern. The introduction of the “Impact Player” rule has come under fire for potentially stalling the development of genuine all-rounders. By allowing teams to substitute a specialist batter for a specialist bowler, the necessity for a player to master both skills is diminished.

Former wicketkeeper Parthiv Patel has echoed these concerns, noting that the rule may be contributing to an all-rounder crisis within the national squad, leaving India vulnerable during crucial overseas matches where versatility is key.

Looking Ahead: The Road to Recovery

As India prepares for upcoming tours in Zimbabwe and New Zealand, the pressure is on the selection committee. To succeed on the world stage, the focus must shift from franchise success to international sustainability. For a deeper understanding of how international T20 dynamics are shifting, you can explore the latest rankings and match reports on ESPN Cricinfo or the Official ICC website.

The challenge for the selectors is clear: strip away the “IPL make-up” and find the players who can thrive when the conditions are tough and the boundaries are far. Only then can India reclaim its dominance in the T20I format.