JD Vance and the Catholic Church: Navigating a Complex Relationship
The relationship between U.S. Vice President JD Vance and the Catholic Church has been a subject of increasing scrutiny, marked by both praise and pointed disagreements. Cardinal Timothy M. Dolan, recently retired as Archbishop of New York and now co-chief of police chaplains, recently shared insights into his conversations with Vance, revealing a nuanced dynamic.
A Public Rebuke and a Private Apology
In a February 19th interview with EWTN News “In Depth,” Cardinal Dolan recounted a discussion with Vance following the Vice President’s January 26, 2025, comments on CBS News’ “Face the Nation.” Vance had suggested that the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) wasn’t a “good partner in commonsense immigration enforcement” and questioned whether their involvement in resettlement programs was driven by humanitarian concerns or financial gain, specifically referencing over $100 million in funding. He stated the USCCB “needs to actually look in the mirror a little bit and recognize that when they receive over $100 million to help resettle illegal immigrants, are they worried about humanitarian concerns or are they actually worried about their bottom line?”
Cardinal Dolan described Vance’s comments as “scurrilous” and untrue. He revealed that Vance later apologized for the remarks, acknowledging they were “out of line.” This exchange highlights a significant point of contention between the Vice President and a leading voice within the Catholic hierarchy.
The USCCB and Immigration Policy
Vance’s criticisms came amidst a period of significant change in U.S. immigration policy. Just two days before his “Face the Nation” appearance, the Trump administration had suspended a decades-long federal partnership with the USCCB and nine other national refugee resettlement agencies. This move followed President Trump’s executive order halting the U.S. Refugee Assistance Program, impacting the USCCB’s resettlement efforts and leading to staff reductions. The USCCB subsequently filed a lawsuit seeking reimbursement for resettlement services, which was later voluntarily dismissed. Learn more about the USCCB’s stance on immigration.
Areas of Agreement and Disagreement
Despite their disagreement on immigration, Cardinal Dolan expressed admiration for Vance on other issues, praising his views on “the family,” “babies,” “patriotism,” and “the beauty of what the United States stands for.” However, the Cardinal also voiced concerns about Vance’s earlier stance on Ukraine, noting his lack of strong support before assuming the vice presidency.
Catholic Social Teaching on Immigration
The core of the disagreement lies in differing interpretations of Catholic social teaching on immigration. This teaching emphasizes a balance between the right to migrate, a nation’s right to regulate its borders, and the obligation to do so with justice and mercy. The USCCB has consistently advocated for comprehensive immigration reform that reflects these principles. Catholic Relief Services provides further insight into this teaching.
Cardinal Dolan, drawing a baseball analogy, acknowledged that no one is perfect, even comparing Vance to baseball legend Stan Musial. The relationship between JD Vance and the Catholic Church remains a complex one, characterized by both areas of alignment and significant points of contention. It’s a dynamic that will likely continue to unfold as Vance’s political career progresses.
