Max Scherzer to the Rescue? Why a Reunion with the Blue Jays Makes Sense
The Toronto Blue Jays entered the 2026 MLB season brimming with confidence in their starting pitching depth. However, the first day of Spring Training brought discouraging news: two key pitchers are facing significant time on the injured list. Shane Bieber is battling forearm fatigue and will miss the start of the regular season, while Bowden Francis will undergo UCL reconstructive surgery, sidelining him for the entire year. This sudden depletion of depth necessitates a strategic move, and a familiar face – future Hall of Famer Max Scherzer – could be the answer.
The Blue Jays aren’t in need of a long-term, high-priced ace like Lucas Giolito or Zac Gallen. What they require is a reliable veteran capable of providing quality innings, particularly as Bieber recovers. Max Scherzer fits this profile perfectly, allowing the team to avoid another significant financial commitment this offseason. Reports indicate Toronto has already expressed interest in bringing back the three-time Cy Young Award winner.
A Veteran Focused on One Last Run
At this stage of his illustrious career, with retirement looming, Max Scherzer is likely prioritizing opportunity over a massive contract. He’s seeking one last chance at championship glory, and the Blue Jays offer a compelling path. He’s proven he’s willing to accept any role that maximizes the team’s chances of winning.
Scherzer came agonizingly close with Toronto in 2025. Despite missing a portion of the season due to injury, he consistently delivered five innings per start upon his return, contributing to a 9-8 record in his outings and helping the Blue Jays return to the postseason after a one-year absence. His impact extended beyond the regular season.
Playoff Performance and a Familiar Feel
The 41-year-old veteran shone during the 2025 MLB Playoffs, posting a 1-0 record with a 3.77 ERA and 11 strikeouts in 14.1 innings across three starts. He even took the mound in the pivotal Game 7 of the World Series, leaving the game with a 3-1 lead over the Los Angeles Dodgers. While the final outcome wasn’t what the Blue Jays hoped for, Scherzer demonstrated his ability to perform under immense pressure.
He’s already become a fan favorite in Toronto, and a reunion would be welcomed by the fanbase. More importantly, it addresses the immediate need for starting pitching depth. Bringing back Max Scherzer isn’t just a smart baseball move; it’s a gesture that acknowledges his contributions and offers him a chance to finish what he started. The Blue Jays should seriously consider bringing him back for the 2026 season.
For more information on MLB players and team news, visit MLB.com.
