Sheetz Legal Battle Reaches Ohio Supreme Court

CENTERVILLE, OH – The ongoing legal dispute between the City of Centerville and convenience store chain Sheetz has now reached the Ohio Supreme Court. The case centers around Sheetz’s proposal to build a new location along Far Hills Avenue, on the site currently occupied by Elsa’s restaurant.

News Center 7’s Xavier Hershovitz will provide live coverage of the proceedings on News Center 7 Daybreak, from 4:25 a.m. to 7 a.m. This case has drawn significant attention, highlighting the complexities of local zoning regulations and business development.

The Core of the Dispute

Sheetz filed a civil suit against the City of Centerville after its application to build was denied. The company argues that the city’s decision was unwarranted. During Wednesday’s arguments, Sheetz’s legal team sought permission to file separate lawsuits for damages. However, Centerville countered that the statute of limitations for such claims has expired.

Previous Court Rulings

A Montgomery County Court previously ruled in favor of Sheetz, stating that the city improperly denied the building application. Centerville appealed this decision to the Second District Court of Appeals, which upheld the lower court’s ruling, instructing the city to adhere to the initial decision. The city then escalated the case further by appealing to the Ohio Supreme Court in December, directly challenging the Court of Appeals’ judgment.

Centerville’s Stance

Centerville maintains that its City Council unanimously determined the proposed Sheetz location was inconsistent with the surrounding properties, violating the city’s unified development ordinance. This ordinance aims to ensure harmonious development that aligns with the character of existing neighborhoods.

News Center 7’s James Brown reached out to the city for comment on Wednesday’s arguments but did not receive a response. Sheetz’s attorney anticipates a decision from the Supreme Court will take several months.

What’s Next?

News Center 7 will continue to monitor this developing story and provide updates as they become available. The outcome of this case could set a precedent for future development projects in Centerville and potentially across Ohio. For more information on zoning laws and development regulations, you can visit the International City/County Management Association website.

©2025 Cox Media Group